Kutup Aytekin reviews Paul Langley and Andrew Leyshon’s Fintech Capital: The Digital Transformation of Everyday Money and Finance (Zone Books, 2026), 336 pp.
Over the last couple of decades, several companies have started to deploy emerging digital technologies in the financial services industry. Having established themselves in the financial sector, these Fintech companies have become more relevant to people’s everyday lives. In their book “Fintech Capital: The Digital Transformation of Everyday Money and Finance,” Paul Langley and Andrew Leyshon examine these Fintech companies, how they operate, and the implications of their operations on people’s everyday financial relations. The book has two main theoretical components. First, it theorizes the nature of Fintech capital and argues that Fintech capital is a combination of financial, money-dealing, and rentier capital types. Second, it analyzes how Fintech capital is constituted and highlights the distinct political-economic processes that produce Fintech capital.
The overall narrative the authors offer has several strengths. The most important is their theoretical framework, which anchors its definition of Fintech capital in distinct categories of capital (financial capital, money-dealing capital, and rentier capital). The authors extensively refer to Marx in depicting all these categories. While the book’s Marxist lens remains palpable throughout the book, it fades into the background at times. In such cases, the authors fill the void with other traditions, such as platform studies, valuation studies, and decolonial theory. Thus, while Marxism is at the center of the authors’ theoretical framework, several other approaches gain salience when the original Marxist ethos gets stretched. The coexistence of multiple theoretical approaches creates a certain tension within the book, but the authors manage it well by carefully welding distinct traditions together.
Langley and Leyshon’s theory synchronizes well with their critical approach towards Fintech capital. The authors carve out five distinct processes that shape Fintech capital as we know it. First, the authors introduce platformization as a means for Fintech companies to reconfigure how people engage with monetary and financial services. In this context, platforms act as infrastructures with two main functions: enclosing the users within the platform’s boundaries and extracting rents by capitalizing on this confinement. Second, they argue that ‘datafication’ turns user data into an asset that Fintech firms use to facilitate capturing rents. Third, they add ‘monopolization’ as a layer and underline how monopoly ownership of platform technologies, data assets and state-granted banking licenses leads Fintech toward positions of dominance.
Fourth, the authors show how colonization (both the legacy of colonial banking that excluded most Africans from formal finance and present-day “digital colonization”) creates opportunities for Fintech companies. They argue that the financial inclusion agenda promoted by development institutions, which casts mobile money as empowering and modernizing, in fact reproduces colonial relations in which value is expropriated from subordinated populations and transferred elsewhere. Fifth, they analyze how the rise of Fintech has been sustained by a capitalization process. The main drivers of this process were venture capital funds and corporate investors, whose investments in Fintech startups were fueled by the low-interest-rate conjuncture that ended in 2022. The authors point out that the capitalization of Fintech companies by venture investments has been crucial in their emergence as a distinct type of capital.
Langley and Leyshon arrive at these five processes partly through the existing literature on financial and digital capitalism, and partly through their theoretical framework. They present platformization and datafication as novel processes of digital capitalism, and draw on the existing literature on these topics. In terms of their theoretical framework, they draw on Marx and classical political economy, but emphasize monopolies grounded in the ownership of assets that generate rents, rather than “monopoly capitalism” as a distinct stage of capitalist development. While covering colonization, they cover the place of colonialism in Marx’s historical narrative, and Evgeny Morozov’s additions to Marxist thought on colonialism. For the capitalization chapter, they start from Marx’s concept of “fictitious capital,” but then depart from it, following Fabian Muniesa and colleagues in treating capitalization as a matter of valuation and assetization rather than the creation of fictitious claims.
As Langley and Leyshon point out in the introduction, their argument questions the predominant techno-solutionist approach to Fintech companies, which stipulates that Fintech will mitigate global economic and social challenges through its integration of cutting-edge technology into monetary and financial operations. The five processes they outline and the critical theoretical lens they utilize in exploring such processes discredit the techno-solutionist position.
Another aspect that makes the book relevant for contemporary discussions is its contribution to the broader discussions on capitalism’s present and future. Looking at the great transformations that have happened in the global economy’s organization, certain accounts have focused on how the capitalist system got restructured through the rise of finance or the emergence of platform capitalism. Some other accounts, such as those of Durand and Varoufakis, have made more radical arguments on how the nature of the capitalist mode of production experienced a techno-feudal mutation, or how capitalism as we know it has died. In their book, Langley and Leyshon make a more moderate argument, highlighting that the rising prominence of Fintech companies does not signal a new stage in capitalism’s development. Instead, they perceive emergent Fintech capital as a novel variety of capital. Their realistic assessment of the current place of Fintech in the broader capitalist system is compelling. Still, it would be reasonable to expect that as Fintech continues to rapidly grow, the question of whether its rise has fundamentally altered capitalism will become more pressing.
Among all the other valuable observations and analyses the book brings to the table, the case studies it covers and their geographical diversity may be the most valuable. Langley and Leyshon do an excellent job of highlighting how distinct Fintech companies have increased their prominence in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. While one of their case studies is about the rise of the Ant Group in China, they also discuss the pivot of US BigTech firms towards financial services. They also examine a small US bank, Evolve Bank & Trust, that profits from renting out its banking license to Fintech firms. The case studies throughout the book are illustrative rather than comparative. Each is assigned to the process it best exemplifies, with limited connections between them despite the authors’ best efforts. Still, the cases yield telling findings. Mercado Libre’s payment arm began in 2003 as a cash escrow system run through agents in local stores and pharmacies, much as Alipay began as a workaround for online payments in cash-dominated China: in both cases, Fintech capital built payment infrastructures rather than layering itself on top of card networks. And in sub-Saharan Africa, MTN’s mobile money business earned 42 percent of its revenues in 2023 from fees charged when users cash out, and 14 percent from interest on the balances users hold in their wallets.
While the book skillfully advances our understanding of Fintech capital, it falls short on certain dimensions. Most importantly, the book ends with a coda that restates the main contributions and the authors’ thoughts about Fintech’s future. This is not problematic by itself, as there are countless books that do a good job in analyzing their subject matter and leaving the analysis at that point. However, this becomes a problem in Langley and Leyshon’s case due to their critical stance and theoretical framework. As indicated before, the authors rely on a highly critical theoretical lens that draws on Marxist thought. The logical extension of such an analysis would be at least some deliberation on how to push back against this emergent type of capital, which encloses users inside its platforms, extracts rents from them, and uses its monopoly power to entrench its dominant position in the market. The authors anticipate this objection: in the introduction they explain that they deliberately refrain from reading forms of capital primarily in political terms, and in the coda they argue that understanding Fintech capital is itself politically empowering. This is a reasonable defense, but it keeps the analysis at a distance from the question of agency. The absence of a substantiated discussion on who or what might constrain Fintech capital leaves the reader with a feeling of incompleteness.
Furthermore, Langley and Leyshon’s narrative on the future regulation of Fintech economies in the coda shows certain cracks. They rightly argue that technical debates over which Fintech institutions should be regulated, and how, narrow the political horizon. They also hit the right chord when they suggest that regulation should be organized around what is genuinely useful to people and protects their autonomy, rather than around market consumption and consumer freedom. However, the main concern here is who exactly would do such rethinking and implement a radically new framework of regulations on Fintech capital. Which political actor has sufficient power to regulate rent extraction against the growing clout and lobbying power of Fintech companies?
In reality, the most effective constraint against the rise of Fintech capital has been an authoritarian state. The authors actually exemplify this in one of their case studies, where they look at Ant Group in China and how the state eventually restricted Ant’s rentierism. Although we do have examples of public alternatives, such as Brazil’s Pix, an instant payment system run by the central bank and free for individuals, we are still far away from a credible democratic framework that can curtail Fintech capital. In such a context, arguments on changing the nature of regulation offer little help against Fintech capital.
Ultimately, Langley and Leyshon masterfully carve out Fintech as an emergent form of capital. They conduct an excellent analysis of the specific processes that allow it to thrive and how its proliferation manifests in distinct contexts. Their theoretical framework and its application to their analysis are rigorous, but the book fails to adequately theorize potential remedies in response to such proliferation. Nevertheless, the strengths of the book easily offset the shortcomings. Langley and Leyshon provide a much-needed framework for future scholars who aspire to analyze a rapidly growing segment of capital that gets dramatically transformed along the way.
Kutup Aytekin is an assistant editor of the Political Economy and Inequalities section.
